If an individual is considered to be tax resident simultaneously in two treaty countries (e.g. Latvia and Lithuania) according to their national law, the dispute over the person’s tax resident status will be resolved by treaty article 4(4), which provides for consecutively assessing the following criteria:
In evaluating a permanent home as the first treaty criterion, we need to consider the OECD commentaries. The commentaries on treaty article 4(2)(a) state that the person has a permanent home in a particular country if he retains it for his permanent use, not simply for staying at a certain place where the circumstances of the situation clearly show that the stay is temporary.
The OECD commentaries on treaty article 4 state that in order to establish with which of the two countries the person has closer personal and economic ties (the centre of vital interests), we need to evaluate the person’s family ties, public activities in the relevant country, occupation and profession, political and cultural activities, place of business, property, and other circumstances. And all these criteria should be evaluated as a set of circumstances, not each one separately. If these criteria do not make it possible to determine the person’s tax residence country, the next criterion to assess is an habitual abode.
The OECD guidance on Covid-19 explains that it may be difficult to determine residence in Covid-19 circumstances for a number of reasons, so an habitual abode should be taken as the decisive criterion during the emergency situation, unless this can be done through the criterion of a permanent home being available in a particular country or the centre of vital interests.
According to the OECD commentaries, an habitual abode within the meaning of tax treaties is a term and test for determining the country where the person stays more frequently, for longer periods and more regularly, and which is part of the person’s usual routine. However, the OECD commentaries state that an habitual abode does not mean the country where the person spends a greater number of days.
In this regard the lawmaker has stated that in evaluating the situation around the restrictions imposed because of Covid-19, we should consider, for instance, the following conditions:
Although neither the State Revenue Service nor the Ministry of Finance has published their position on applying the OECD guidance on Covid-19, PwC has received the opinion that Latvia as an OECD member is applying treaty provisions and following the OECD’s international guidelines on how those provisions should be applied in Covid-19 circumstances.
The OECD guidance on Covid-19 explains how to read and apply the OECD commentaries on treaty article 4 to determine tax residence in the context of the Covid-19 emergency situation. Specifically, the OECD guidance on Covid-19 states that in most situations where an individual’s tax residence country could change, we need to consider the extraordinary and temporary force majeure nature of the consequences of the pandemic. So the OECD guidance on Covid-19 takes the view that none of the circumstances related to the pandemic may change the person’s tax residence country.
The OECD guidance on Covid-19 does not make any new recommendations for applying treaty provisions but describes how those provisions should be applied and interpreted in force majeure circumstances based on the OECD commentaries published earlier.
In their reply, the Latvian tax authorities state that the travel and other types of restrictions that Latvia and other countries have imposed as well as their impact should be taken into account as force majeure circumstances in assessing situations and particular cases affected by the measures taken to contain the pandemic.
If you have any comments on this article please email them to lv_mindlink@pwc.com
Ask questionWe use cookies to make our site work well for you and so we can continually improve it. The cookies that keep the site functioning are always on. We use analytics and marketing cookies to help us understand what content is of most interest and to personalise your user experience.
It’s your choice to accept these or not. You can either click the 'I accept all’ button below or use the switches to choose and save your choices.
For detailed information on how we use cookies and other tracking technologies, please visit our cookies information page.
These cookies are necessary for the website to operate. Our website cannot function without these cookies and they can only be disabled by changing your browser preferences.
These cookies allow us to measure and report on website activity by tracking page visits, visitor locations and how visitors move around the site. The information collected does not directly identify visitors. We drop these cookies and use Adobe to help us analyse the data.
These cookies help us provide you with personalised and relevant services or advertising, and track the effectiveness of our digital marketing activities.